Experience The Brotherhood

Brotherhood of Thieves Pub

Our street level, historic 1840's Whaling Bar and Tavern.

Reserve A Table

Notch Whiskey Bar

Spend an evening in our upscale whiskey bar featuring Notch, the top rated small batch single malt in the world- distilled right here in Nantucket.

Dessert & Cordials Menu

Cisco Surf Bar

Our vibrant upstairs bar with a beach vibe and live music on weekends. 

Sushi Menu

Cisco Beer Garden

Join us this season on our patio or in the beer garden - with a super cool secret bar!

Main Menu